General
LeMay expressed surprised at using the atomic bomb against the Japanese
as he felt no military targets remained – his incendiary bombing had
already destroyed nearly everything. The use of it is explained by
Truman’s desire “that the [atomic] bomb would provide diplomatic
benefits by making the Soviets more tractable” in postwar negotiations.
--Bernhard Thuersam
Incendiary Raids on Japanese Cities
“Army
Air Force General Curtis LeMay ordered the American strategic bombers
to begin night incendiary raids on Japanese cities rather than
attempting daylight precision bombing of industrial centers. The [B-29]
Superfortresses honed their skills in three raids against Tokyo. A
single bombing raid in February [1945] destroyed at least 25,000
buildings. But the most devastation attack of the war, more deadly
perhaps than both atomic bombs together, occurred on March 9, 1945.
Two
hundred seventy-nine Superfortresses, sortieing from Guam, Saipan and
Tinian, dropped firebombs from 7,000 feet on Tokyo’s residential areas.
The paper and wood city erupted in inescapable flames. Sixteen square
miles were completely destroyed.
During
this single raid, approximately 100,000 Japanese civilians were killed.
Many died from being scalded as they tried to save themselves by
crowding into the city’s canals, which boiled. By comparison, 100,000
civilians died in the Hiroshima nuclear attack, while 35,000 died at
Nagasaki. The raid lasted three hours. American Superfortress pilots
and crews in the last wave vomited in their aircraft from the stench of
burning flesh carried to their mile-high altitude.
Over
successive days, the B-29s progressed to other Japanese cities. The
United States burned Nagoya, Osaka, Yokohama, then Kobe. Then the
bombers moved on to the lesser cities. As Japan had few [anti-aircraft]
guns left, the B-29s could strike with impunity.
Citizens
were warned with leaflets that their neighborhood would be razed. But
few had anywhere to go. By the end of the war, nearly 400,000 Japanese
civilians would be killed, mostly in American bombing attacks.
[From]
April 1 until mid-June 1945, less than three divisions of Japanese held
out in Okinawa, without support….Fourteen Japanese divisions and
five….brigades protected Kyushu. President Truman later claimed, and
many American sources agreed, that an invasion of Japan could have cost a
million American casualties. This is far from accurate.
General
Dwight Eisenhower said that he felt that the atomic bombing was
unnecessary from the point of view of saving American lives. Admiral
William Leahy, Secretary of War Henry Stimson, Secretary of the Navy
James Forrestal, and Army Air General Henry “Hap” Arnold, all thought
that dropping the bomb was unnecessary. Japan was broken and would have
surrendered without an invasion.
The
Japanese had no fuel, fewer than 10,000 trucks, almost no ability to
manufacture weapons or ammunition, nor to transport supplies to Japan.
They had almost no tanks left and remained wholly unable to defend
themselves from air attack. Famine and disease threatened most of the
population. Millions of Japanese civilians remained homeless. One by
one, their cities were being razed. Japan’s air forces had been ruined,
her navy wrecked. The bulk of Japan’s army was withering away in South
Asia.
Nevertheless,
on August 6, the first atomic bomb, dubbed “Little Boy,” was dropped on
Hiroshima. [Three days] after that, the second atomic bomb, “Fat Man,”
was detonated over Nagasaki.”
(Danger’s Hour, The Story of the USS Bunker Hill, Maxwell Taylor Kennedy, Simon & Schuster, 2008, pp. 195-196; page 443)
Both Hiroshima and Nagasaki are sad places. I seriously doubt there was a real need to drop the bombs.
ReplyDeleteTino
Nor Dresden.
Deletebut if one takes an errie note
ReplyDeletenobody has used a nuke after japan in all these years
ever wonder why?
Wildflower
As I remember, seems like we killed about as many when we firebombed Dresden.
DeleteAfter we dropped the bombs, the Soviets has stolen our designs and suddenly there were plenty of countries possessing nukes. Capishe?
DeleteThey were good at that as they have been infiltrating every aspect of our society.
DeleteYeah and there was no "need" for the attack on Pearl Harbor, the Bataan Death March, the houses of forced pleasure for Japans soldiers, the medical experiments on "monkeys", the wholesale slaughter on innocents who were considered subspecies by the Japanese. The Japanese were famous for enslaving and torturing entire peoples. Had they won, the evidence is plentiful that our parents lives would have been more than hellish. We need to focus on the enemy of today, the people who are now running the US Govt.
ReplyDeleteWe need to focus on the enemy of today, the people who are now running the US Govt.
DeleteAmen.
I delivered the Asheville-Citizen-Times newspapers on the days the bombs dropped on the two Japanese cities with no idea what that news meant. Then I took Nuclear Engineering courses at NC State and made a decision to focus on Chemical Engineering rather than Nuclear. Just a hunch. And then I helped manufacture the submarine missiles to carry the nuclear warheads to any city on earth.
ReplyDeleteIn the eighties I spent months in Osaka and the Shiga Province training Hercules people to operate a film plant. Everywhere I went I was treated as royalty. My favorite uncle went down on the USS Houston, heavy cruiser, in the Java Sea in 1942.
I do not hold the Japanese people responsible for the atrocities, any more than I hold the American people responsible for the half-million Iraqis we have killed, who never did attack us. The last sentence of David343's reply says it all for me. I hold the insane leaders of Japan and the US responsible for the insane wars which mostly killed civilians.
Today, one of my favorite quotes is the following:
“You cannot talk like sane men around a peace table while the atomic bomb itself is ticking beneath it. Do not treat the atomic bomb as a weapon of offense; do not treat it as an instrument of the police. Treat the bomb for what it is: the visible insanity of a civilization that has ceased...to obey the laws of life.”- Lewis Mumford, 1946
And this of the immortal Gen. Smedley Butler, "War is a racket."
I just thought I was a rocket scientist. Now I know that I was a Racket Scientist.
"War is a racket."
Delete"War Is A Racket" Video USMC General Smedley Butler
http://freenorthcarolina.blogspot.com/2012/05/war-is-racket-video-usmc-general.html
Here richly, with ridiculous display,
The Politician’s corpse was laid away.
While all of his acquaintances sneered and slanged, I wept:
For I had longed to see him hanged.
--Hilaire Belloc
If the Japs were defeated and would have surrendered without the Atomic bomb being dropped, then - - - WHY didn't they?
ReplyDeleteWhy did it take TWO (02) bombs before they got the message?
I don't feel any regret for living in the ONLY nation on Earth to have successfully waged a nuclear war on a foreign power.
On the other hand, I lived in Ashiya Air Force Base, Fukuoka Prefect, on the island of Kyushu, Japan when I was in the Second Grade, and when I was in the old Republic of Viet Nam, I went to Japan on R&R to attend EXPO '70.
Boy, was it ever neat!
I rode the Bullet Train, which at the time, was the FASTEST train in the World!
I prefer the Indochinese though Thais are gracious and Filipinos are dear also. I believe the PI and Vietnam were joined eons ago as they share similar food and if you visually move the two land masses together, it seems to work. Their facial characteristics are very similar also.
DeleteWith all due respect, Sir, the political facts played a huge role in why the Emperor refused to surrender - mainly due to the Soviets.
DeleteHe tried several months prior to first bomb to contact the US to surrender, but the Soviets prevented it and managed to get the Potsdam Declaration signed instead, which handed (thanks FDR and Churchill) over half of Europe to the communists.
As the Emperor was considered a god, the whole affair was not so simple as some would like to think.
Yup, WHY didn't they? You may want to educate yourself on the subject further. While at it, some research as to why the whole war started could be interesting.
Sincerely, Semper Fi,
Tino
P.S. Having lived in Japan, I can only concur it's a beautiful country.
why the whole war started
DeleteSeems that a posted something on that recently.
"The world is governed by people far different from those imagined by the public." - Benjamin Disraeli
ReplyDeleteMost unfortunately.
Delete