Tuesday, July 17, 2018

The German Soldiers of World War II: Why They Were the Best, and Why They Still Lost

Via Ol' Remus 

  Soldiers like these fought with unmatched ability, daring and resourcefulness

The German soldiers of World War II have often been portrayed, both during the war and in the decades since, as simple-minded, unimaginative and brutish. Hollywood movies and popular U.S. television shows have for years contrasted confident, able and “cool” American GIs with slow-witted, cynical and cruel Germans.
 
“Propaganda is an inescapable ingredient of modern conflict,” British journalist and historian Max Hastings has noted. “In the Second World War, it was considered essential for the struggle to defeat the German army that the peoples of the Grand [Allied] Alliance should be convinced of the qualitative superiority of their fighting men to those of the enemy. One [American] dogface or one [British] tommy was worth three wooden-headed krauts. Hitler’s robots could never match the imagination and initiative of Allied soldiers on the battlefield …” Major wartime American motion pictures portrayed German soldiers as dull-witted and simplistic. In the decades since the war, Hastings notes, “a spirit of military narcissism, nourished by such films as ‘The Longest Day,’ ‘A Bridge Too Far’ and ‘The Battle of the Bulge,’ has perpetuated mythical images of the Allied and German armies.”[1] 

4 comments:

  1. I had an uncle in 3rd Army. His view was the regular army would come apart if you killed the officer and senior sergeant. The SS troupes were another story as they were at a higher level. My uncle also stated the SS were not taken prisoner.

    He talked of this once, after I returned from Desert Storm over a bottle of 1942 cognac. He also told me about getting shot in the ass at Bastogne. Other than that conversation he never spoke of WWII.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Brock,
    Cool story!! 'They were the "Best" but still "Lost!!"... This story tweeked my ol' brain and a few points came to mind... I recall someone saying.. "Yup, Hitler had a great "Ground War" with his "Panzer's" and "Blitzkreig!!" .. but he had one small problem with that..... "His ROOF LEAKED!!!!!!" The Americans by Day and the Brits. by night!! Carpet Bombing and More!! Remember the US War Effort!! "Rosey The Riveter!!" At our production height, we were rolling out Airplanes faster than candy mints!! B-24 Liberators one every 5 minutes (I Think??) My High School Algebra teacher was a WASP and flew them!! Yes there were other "Issues" but you still have to look at the "Big Picture!!"
    Audentes, Fortuna Ivat!!!,
    skybill

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks and as I remember, if we bombed a factory it would be back up in 3 days. Simplely amazing!

      Delete