Grant’s
unlimited supply of troops made him indifferent to high casualties from
massed assaults, thus earning him the nickname “Butcher”; it was his
policy to refuse humanitarian prisoner exchanges which would have saved
the lives of thousands of captured Northern men. His postwar
administration as president was described as “extravagant, wasteful and
corrupt . . . destitute of principle,” and “held together only by the
cohesive power of public plunder.”
Bernhard Thuersam, Chairman
North Carolina War Between the States Sesquicentennial Commission
"Unsurpassed Valor, Courage and Devotion to Liberty"
"The Official Website of the North Carolina WBTS Sesquicentennial"
Grant’s Cold Philosophy of War
“It
is most unfortunate that the name of Grant cannot be added to [the]
list of those of the [North’s] greater leaders who sought to lessen the
horrors of war. It seems clear, however, that while ultimately
displaying a splendid magnanimity at Appomattox that must evermore be a
tribute to him, General Grant must have known of the terrible suffering
of the prisoners of war and of the desolation created by Sherman and
Sheridan, if indeed, he did not sanction and encourage the forces of
destruction.
Let
us believe that he could not have fully recognized the extent of this
suffering, and that he conscientiously thought that final victory would
be hastened by these processes, ignoring the present terror and the
aftermath of bitterness.
Such
has been the cold philosophy of some commanders at other times and
places. Because of his simple greatness at Appomattox, therefore, it
must be assumed that Grant did not realize what was being done, just as,
during his eight years, as President, he refrained from checking the
horrors of Reconstruction – now generally recognized to have been a
process of despoliation and ruin carried on in times of peace under the
guise of law and order.”
(The Women of the South in War Times, Matthew Page Andrews, Norman, Remington Company, 1920, pg. 225)
Rationalizing atrocities because they supposedly "bring the fighting to a quicker end" is a favorite excuse of military commanders who violate basic human decencies. The end can never, even in war, justify the means, or we become no better than savages.
ReplyDeleteAmen.
Delete