Monday, April 22, 2019

Southern Fears of Northern Interests

Image result for Richard Henry Lee  quotes
“To preserve liberty, it is essential that the whole body of people always possess arms and be taught alike, especially when young, how to use them.”

Patrick Henry of Virginia was one of the most vocal opponents of the constitution which eventually would supersede the Articles of Confederation. He predicted that members of Congress would become a new aristocracy and vote themselves large salaries; that national control over State militia was dangerous to freedom; that Northern commercial interests would menace the South. James Madison could only reply that the “Constitution was not perfect, but as good as might have been made.”www.Circa1865.org  The Great American Political Divide

Southern Fears of Northern Interests

“The Virginia delegates returning from Philadelphia had hardly reached their firesides when a long campaign began against the Constitution. In letters, pamphlets and speeches there poured forth almost every conceivable argument against it. It contained no bill of rights, and its adoption would lead to the destruction of personal liberties; it would bring back monarchy; it would create a ruling aristocracy; and it protected the abominable slave trade.

But above all, the Constitution was a dagger aimed at the South, and its point must be blunted or avoided. It must be amended to protect against all these evils. Were it not possible to secure changes, Virginia must think of creating a Southern federation in which the rights of person, republicanism, and Southern interests would be effectively defended.

One of the more moderate enemies of the Constitution was Richard Henry Lee . . . [writing that] “the Constitution threatened Southern interests; and he emphatically declared that Congressional authority to regulate commerce was a menace to the South. Said he:

“In this congressional legislature a bare majority can enact commercial laws, so that the representatives of seven Northern States, as they will have a majority, can, by law, create the most oppressive monopolies upon the five Southern States, whose circumstances and productions are essentially different from theirs, although not a single man of their voters are the representatives of, or amenable to, the people of the Southern States . . . it is supposed that the policy of the Southern States will prevent such abuses! But how feeble, sir, is policy when opposed to interest among trading people.”

Far more forthcoming in denunciation was Benjamin Harrison, who wrote to Washington: “If the constitution is carried into effect, the States south of the [Potomac], will be little more than appendages to those northward of it. . . . In the nature of things they must sooner or later, establish a tyranny, not inferior to the triumvirate or centum viri of Rome.”

Equally vigorous language was used by George Mason [who] wanted amendments protecting both personal and States’ rights. He feared the Constitution would bring either oligarchy or monarchy and Northern dominion.

[Patrick] Henry . . . aroused the fears of men indebted to British merchants: those grasping enemy creditors who would make use of the Federal courts-to-be . . . [and that] the Northerners would control that government, and they would discriminate grievously against the Southern people whenever they could secure gain for themselves.”

(The First South, John Richard Allen, LSU Press, 1961, excerpts pp. 111-114)

2 comments:

  1. The Militia are trying to protect our country which is their right
    and were arrested. Two American soldiers were detained by
    Mexican soldier on U.S. soil. Like Lou Dobbs said, he couldn't
    believe the American soldier turned over his weapon to the Mexican
    soldiers. I couldn't either:
    https://conspiracyanalyst.org/2019/04/23/mexican-soldiers-detain-american-soldiers-on-u-s-soil-government-response/
    Like Col. MacGregor said, "Mexico is an act of war and not an
    ally."
    Immigration is a form of war in which the violence is delayed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. https://freenorthcarolina.blogspot.com/2019/04/mexican-soldiers-detain-american.html

      Immigration is a form of war in which the violence is delayed.

      Hadn't heard that before.

      Delete